- Nov 2, 2022
- 401
- 1,014
Elly does seem a shortened version of Danielle, but an uncommon one, so it's not entirely unreasonable that MC didn't make that connection. He's pretty amazingly dense to all the hints and clues about Elly being Danielle. And while Ashley's feed wouldn't show the pics of Elly, it seems odd that she would have followed MC, but not browsed his relatively small collection of photos.iirc Lennon comes from the Beatles. They even talked about it with MC.
I played all the routes as much as possible, I don't think I've missed any but it's possible.
I thought it was like Danielle > Elle > Elly but maybe I am wrong. Photogram works a little different though, if you are tagged to a photo you see that in your feed. So even if it's slim, there is a possibility that Ashley have not seen Elly&MC photos. In any case, I definitely agree with you it's extremely weird she never questioned MC about Elly.
Btw, dad seemed genuinely wanted to reconnect with MC but once MC asked about the cabin, he risked the only reconnection opportunity. Also MC said his father loved nature and the cabin but stopped taking MC there after awhile but it was not a reason not going there without MC but as we know the cabin in rundown state so dad stopped going there altogether. Which indicates whatever happened there, it must be huge. Because it gave MC a trauma, possible reason for Ashley and Elly moved away, possible reason for MC's parents divorce, the reason they separated MC and Danielle the inseparable duo, also they avoid the topic at all cost.
One of my(far too many) theories about the cabin is that perhaps MC and Danielle had sex there, and got caught by their parents. While in bed with Elly, she says she's not a virgin, but her tone, words, and expressions seemed like she was trying to jog MC's memory that he took her virginity when they were younger, but he repressed the memory. It may be that the blood he sees during hypnosis(I only saw the non-sexual hypnosis, not sure if it comes up during the sexual hypnosis) may have been referring to taking Danielle's virginity.